- Go to the Beach
- Enter the Migrator
- Click the stairs
- Click the notice near the Captain’s Quarter Doors.
- A blue window and a notice will pop up. Click yes on the blue notice.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0e3b9/0e3b9b1c1a4e2bc31b45010169ccdc77c3cccfee" alt="club penguin cheats Club Penguin Eye Patch Pin Cheat"
You should now have the Eye Patch Pin. Cool!
-Dino Boy7
(Credit to ClubPenguinCP)